Are Polypropylene Bags Effective as DIY Face Masks for COVID-19?

Can Polypropylene Bags be Used to Make Effective and Breathable Homemade DIY Masks

In the rush to make homemade masks, many people are wondering whether non-woven polypropylene bags are effective at filtering viruses. These bags are incredibly popular in places like Asia and Africa, where they are a common alternative to flimsy plastic shopping bags.

 

Why Non-Woven Polypropylene Bags Make Great Homemade Masks

 

These shopping bags are great candidates for masks because:

  1. They’re durable.
  2. Stores often give them away for free.
  3. They are easy to find.

In fact, in some African countries, markets hand them out for free to all shoppers. These bags in Uganda are real-life examples:

 

Nonwoven polypropylene pp shopping bags homemade mask

 

Thus, the bags are promising candidates, but how well do they filter out virus-sized particles? Can they really protect the wearer from viruses like the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus?

What Are Reusable Shopping Bags Made From?

 

Reusable tote bags are made from a non-woven, polypropylene plastic (often referred to as ‘PP’). “Woven” materials are easy to understand. Cotton threads in our T-shirts are woven together.

 

nonwoven polypropylene material close-up

 

The “non-woven” in the name means the plastic is bonded together. One way to do that is to melt the plastic so that it forms together. For example, imagine taking a handful of chocolate chips and melting them into a bar.

 

 

Non-woven polypropylene plastic is also the material used to make masks and HEPA filters. Since masks and HEPA filters can both capture the coronavirus, it would be reasonable to think that these bags might too. Thus, we put it to the test.

 

HEPA Filter Polypropylene PP

 

Testing Polypropylene Bags’ Ability to Capture Viruses

 

In the Smart Air lab, we tested 30 DIY materials including a polypropylene bag to see how well they these DIY mask materials could filter out virus-sized particles.

 

Homemade Mask Test Data Filtration

 

We measured the ability of the polypropylene bag and other materials to capture 0.3-micron particles and 1-micron particles. The SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus measures 0.06-0.14 microns by itself and 5-10 microns when in water droplets.

The polypropylene bag captured 22% of the smaller particles and 42% of the larger particles.

Effectiveness of non-woven polypropylene bags at capturing virus sized particles

 

Doubling The Layers Boosts Effectiveness by One-Half

 

Next, we tested whether adding more layers would significantly increase effectiveness. The data showed that two layers of non-woven shopping bag material filtered 34% of small particles. Three layers more than doubled the particle capture.

 

DIY masks made using multiple layers of non-woven pp shopping bag more effective at capturing viruses

 

How does that compare to masks? Effectiveness of 57% isn’t bad, but it’s still a far cry from the 97% the surgical mask we tested was able to capture.

 

Non-woven polypropylene shopping bag homemade mask not as effective as surgical mask

Polypropylene Makes Decent Filters, But Very Breathable

 

Out of the 30 materials we tested, the polypropylene bag did not capture the most particles. However, it was one of the most breathable materials. A single layer bag was more breathable than a surgical mask and about as breathable as a 100% cotton T-shirt and bandana.

 

non-woven shopping bag breathability compared to cotton t-shirt and bandana

 

Three Layers Make Strong, Breathable Mask

 

Because it’s so breathable, polypropylene can form three layers and still be more breathable than a surgical mask. Thus, a triple-layer non-woven polypropylene mask makes a great candidate for homemade mask material.

Breathability of non-woven polypropylene shopping bag mask compared to surgical mask

Bottom Line: Effectiveness of Polypropylene Bags for Homemade Facemasks

Data shows that polypropylene bags are worse than surgical masks at capturing virus-sized particles. However, the high breathability of polypropylene bags means they can be layered up to make more effective DIY masks, although they still do not come close to the performance of a surgical mask.

 

Learn More: Discover which materials are best for making homemade masks in our ultimate DIY mask material review»


Covid19 coronavirus best masks materials fundraiser

Get the latest clean air tips!

Get updates on masks, air purifiers and air quality delivered straight to your inbox.

8
Leave a Reply

  Subscribe  
Notify of
Kathy

I had heard that a double layer of stretchy chiffon plus a polyester fabric was a good filter for viruses.

arun kumatr

so surgical masks are better than polypropylene face mask for outdoor

Steve

This image says that the filtration efficiency of surgical masks at 0.3 microns is 97%.

I assume that this is a typo, because in your last test (The Ultimate Guide to Homemade Face Masks for Coronavirus) it says that the filtration efficiency of surgical masks @0.3 microns is 75%…?

carlos gutierrez

Hi, great job, thank you for this important service to people. I wonder if one cotton pad (make-up remover) between two layers of NWPP (like a sandwich) make a difference in filtration efficiency… Again thank you.

Nick

Thanks for the test, very interesting! By the way, quote: “57% for 3 layers is not bad, but it’s still a far cry from the 97% the surgical mask we tested was able to capture.” Does this sentence and the picture maybe contain a mistake? In your article “The Ultimate Guide to Homemade Face Masks for Coronavirus” (2020-04-21) you mentioned that the surgical mask filters “only” 75% of all 0.3 micron particles. Or do you mean that not one, but 3 layers of surgical masks capture 97% of all 0.3 micron particles? That would be very interesting, because I was… Read more »

Liz - Smart Air

Hi Nick, Liz here. The 97% is the surgical masks ability on capturing both 0.3 and 1.0 microns.