Which Indian cities have the best air quality?

यह पेज हिंदी में उपलब्ध नहीं है| अंग्रेजी में देखें| For the sake of viewer convenience, the content is shown below in the alternative language. You may click the link to switch the active language.

Which cities in India have the best and worst air pollution? I analyzed data from the World Health Organization’s database of annual particulate pollution (PM2.5) averages for 122 cities. Here’s what I found.

 

Agra Through Mumbai

122 cities is too much for one graph, so I broke it in half. Here’s A through M from highest to lowest.

Here’s that same list in alphabetical order.

Nagaon Through Warangal

Here’s N through Z from highest to lowest.

And here’s that same list in alphabetical order.

Takeaway 1: It helps to be later in the alphabet

For some unknown reason (regional linguistic differences?), you’re better off on average if you’re in an N-Z city (48 micrograms) rather than an A-M city (66 micrograms).

 

Takeaway 2: Only one city is under the WHO annual limit

The World Health Organization’s annual limit is 10 micrograms/m3. Only one city came in under that limit—Tezpur, Assam.

Maybe 10 micrograms is a ridiculous, unattainable limit? It’s true that my university’s city, Chicago, is above that limit (12 micrograms), although New York City is just below it (9 micrograms). Many major developed cities are around 10 micrograms.

 

Takeaway 3: Seven cities are under the looser WHO 24-hour limit

If the 10 microgram limit is too strict, we can try out the looser 24-hour limit of 25 micrograms. Based on that limit, seven cities on the top 10 list make the cut. That’s a meager 6% of cities under this looser limit.

 

India’s Top 10

India’s top 10 cities according to this database are:

  1. Tezpur (6 micrograms)
  2. Pathanamthitta (12)
  3. Hassan (19)
  4. Chitoor (21)
  5. Kollam (22)
  6. Puducherry (22)
  7. Bongaigaon (24)
  8. Madurai (26)
  9. Warangal (26)
  10. Alappuzha (27)

 

India’s Bottom 10

The cities with the worst air according to this database are:

  1. Gwalior (176 micrograms)
  2. Allahabad (170)
  3. Patna (149)
  4. Raipur (144)
  5. Delhi (122)
  6. Ludhiana (122)
  7. Kanpur (115)
  8. Khanna (114)
  9. Firozabad (113)
  10. Lucknow (113)

 

Caveats

Now, this data isn’t perfect. For one, it’s from 2012, so it’s a bit old.

Second, some cities don’t measure PM2.5, so the WHO infers it from the larger PM10 particles (what’s the difference?). I’ve discovered that the WHO database vastly underestimates pollution levels in Beijing compared to my analysis of local data.

To some extent, the exact top and bottom cities are arbitrary. Different articles use different data sources and will come up with different sets of cities. But the bigger picture of air quality across India holds up regardless of the dataset.

 

Breathe safe!

 

P.S. What kind of an answer would this be if there weren’t some solutions in it? After coughing through Beijing’s smog for years, I’ve combed through the data, done my own tests, and found several cheap ways to protect my lungs:

Has there been reputable research on the effectiveness of anti-pollution masks?

Can the Quora community in Delhi come together to think of viable solutions for air pollution in Delhi?

Do air purifiers remove PM2.5?

On average, how long can I wear a 3M N95 face mask before it needs to be disposed?

Thomas is a new Assistant Professor of Behavior Science at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business and the founder of Smart Air, a social enterprise to help people in China breathe clean air without shelling out thousands of dollars for expensive purifiers.

प्रातिक्रिया दे

आपका ईमेल पता प्रकाशित नहीं किया जाएगा. आवश्यक फ़ील्ड चिह्नित हैं *