Why Formaldehyde Detectors Are Not as Effective at Formaldehyde (HCHO) Testing as You Think

formaldehyde detectors

Lots of companies will sell you formaldehyde sensors, but a simple test you can do at home will reveal they are fakes. Formaldehyde detectors routinely react to lots of common gases that are not formaldehyde, making the numbers impossible to interpret. Given that unfortunate fact, here’s what you can do to test formaldehyde in your home.

The Problem – Formaldehyde Build-Up at Home

Have you ever moved into a newly remodeled apartment and smelled that chemical, remodeling smell?

I’m very much not an expert in air pollution, but I am very much a dedicated nerd. And I’ve spent the last five years of my nerd energy researching and testing formaldehyde in China. This series shares the three most important things I’ve learned. 

If you can smell it, you’ve got a problem. Don’t waste time and money testing.

If you can smell that sort of chemical, paint, or cleaner smell, you have a VOC problem in your home. 

Although I’ve seen people say that formaldehyde is colorless and odorless, the fact is it has a strong smell.

I know from my high school dissection activity. The CDC says so too.

But why would I say you shouldn’t bother testing it? I love doing tests! I test the air in my home all the time.

Plus, Taobao has a bunch of formaldehyde testing machines for under 100 RMB. So why not?

Formaldehyde Test

“Formaldehyde detectors” on Taobao react to lots of common gases, not just formaldehyde.

These “formaldehyde detectors” actually react to a large group of gases, including harmful and harmless gases. 

If you have a tester, try a little experiment: eat an orange near the tester. The detector will probably send out an alarm. Formaldehyde! You can see me doing that exact test here.

Smart Air formaldehyde detectors test

These formaldehyde detectors will react to lots of harmless things, like oranges, flowers, and peanut butter.

Formaldehyde detector orange test

Last time I checked, oranges don’t have formaldehyde.

Formaldehyde tester sensor detector

OK, so here’s your other option for testing: take air samples and send them to a lab for testing. That’s OK, but it takes a lot of time and money.

After buying a small army of testing machines, my recommendation is this: even though it sounds unscientific, our noses are pretty good detectors. 

Scientists have done studies to figure out what levels of formaldehyde human noses can detect, and they found that humans can detect really low levels.

Formaldehyde detection limit nose study

How low can our noses go? The US CDC says we should be worried about formaldehyde at 0.1 PPM (2). That’s precisely the level that normal people start to smell formaldehyde.

The US CDC says we should start worrying about formaldehyde at 0.1 PPM, precisely the level at which most humans can start smelling it.


Bottom Line
Bottom Line: </span>The Accuracy of Formaldehyde Detectors<span>

As unscientific as it sounds, our noses are quite sensitive formaldehyde detectors. Unfortunately, commercially available “formaldehyde detectors” provide no insight into formaldehyde.

Smart Air

Read More: 3 Things You Need to Know About Formaldehyde

Part 1: Why formaldehyde testers are fake (and why it’s actually scientific to just use your nose)

Part 2: How long it takes for formaldehyde to off-gas from new and remodeled homes

Part 3: Three data-backed ways to reduce formaldehyde and other VOCs in your home


Free Guide to Breathing Safe

Want to learn more about breathing clean air? Join thousands more and stay up to date on protecting your health.

Subscribe
Notify of

5 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
dimenionk
2023-06-25 9:20 pm

Regarding the orange, the limonene in it reacts with the ozone in the air and makes formaldehyde, so it would be expected to register wouldn’t it ..tho not at a dangerous level I suppose. Interesting idea to use your nose, I like it! The only thing is we become immune to smells and only really notice changes, so you’d need to leave your room/house for a while and return. Not really a problem tho

Alan M
2021-02-22 6:57 am

Thanks for the info, I’m trying to find a good formaldehyde sensor / detector, and am buying a few to test, much like you did I guess.

emma
2019-10-03 2:08 pm

How about those chemical test kit for formaldehyde? Are they accurate?

Who we are
Clean Air Social Enterprise
Smart Air is a certified B Corp on a global mission to make clean air accessible through science, education, and affordable air purification

Subscribe to our newsletter and be part of the clean air movement
The Sqair
Up to 36m² (387ft²)

A stylish, minimalist purifier that blends seamlessly into any modern home

SA600
Up to 60m² (645ft²)

Engineered with dual filters to deliver maximum air purification performance

The Sqair
Up to 36m² (387ft²)
CADR: 508 m³/h
New
SA600
Up to 60m² (645ft²)
CADR: 508 m³/h
Blast Mini Mk II
Up to 89m² (958ft²)
CADR: 743 m³/h
Blast Mk II
Up to 114m² (1,227ft²)
CADR: 950 m³/h

HEPA Filters

Remove PM2.5, PM10, dust, pollen, allergens, and viruses

Carbon Filters

Remove VOCs, smoke, formaldehyde, and odors

CO₂ Monitor

Measure CO₂, temperature, and relative humidity

HEPA Filters
Remove PM2.5, PM10, dust, pollen, allergens, and viruses
Carbon Filters
Remove VOCs, smoke, formaldehyde, and odors
Left Right
CO₂ Monitor
Measure CO₂, temperature, and relative humidity

Latest Articles

Smart Air low cost purifiers

Smart Air is a social enterprise and certified B Corp that offers simple, no-nonsense air purifiers and provides free education to protect people from the harms of air pollution.

Certified B-Corp air purifier company