What combination of air filters do I need to protect against everything?

What combination of air filters do I need to protect against everything?

This will sound like a grand claim, but two filters are all you need. Here’s why (with data).

 

Very Reasonable Reasons To Be Skeptical

Why might you be skeptical? For one, big purifier companies are in an arms race to tell you they have more filters than the next guy. Simpleton Thomas here is telling you you just need two, but these guys have six (proprietary!) layers of filters:

 

6 stage filters air purifier

 

But wait, those guys are stone age chumps, because these guys have seven stages! Also proprietary.

 

7 stage filters air purifier

 

I’m not an expert in air pollution. I’m just a social psychologist who does a lot of research in China. Spending time in China put me on a path to care a lot about the polluted air I often breathe. In the midst of all that caring, I saw purifier companies telling me I needed to spend $2,000 for “the cleanest air guaranteed.” That made me suspicious.

IQAir purifier expensive

 

Does it really cost $2,000 to make these things? Is there really something meaningfully different about “plasma arrays” and imported Swiss HEPA filters?

 

IQAir purifier expensive

 

So I started digging. I found out the technology behind air purifiers is stupidly simple. Purifiers are just fans and filters.

They’re so simple that I “built” my own purifier. It’s just a HEPA filter strapped to a fan. (Here’s how you can build your own DIY purifier.)

DIY air purifier filters

 

But I wanted to know if it really worked. I’m not an expert in air pollution, but I am a scientist, so I understand data at least. I bought a laser particle counter to test for microscopic pollutants in my air. I was pretty geeked.

 

 

The data showed my $30 DIY purifier cut the amount of 0.5 micron particulate in my room by 84% on average. A souped up version with a stronger fan reduced particulate by 97% (I made all the data and methods open source).

 

DIY purifier effectiveness

 

I was so excited I wanted to tell the world. I started a group called Smart Air to ship these no-nonsense purifiers to other air-breathers-in-need. As I started ramping things up from DIY home project to social enterprise, I tested all the filters from all the manufacturers I could find. What I found was that I really just needed two types of filters because of a simple fact about natural kinds:

 

There are essentially two kinds of air pollution. That’s the principle behind why all we need is two filters.

 

1. Particles: HEPA filter

For every particle—and I mean every particle—a HEPA filter is all you need. They’re nothing fancy. They were invented back in the 1940s, and they’re just a mat of synthetic fibers.

 

HEPA filters

 

These capture essentially ALL particles. At first I was misled by the common definition of HEPAs—that they capture 99% of particles 0.3 microns and above.

HEPA filters definition

 

Reality is far weirder. It turns out HEPAs (and masks and furnace filters) are actually better at capturing particles smaller than 0.3 microns.

 

HEPA filters efficiency

 

People have asked me about lots of specific particles—do HEPAs capture dust mites? Pet dander? Asbestos? Bacteria? Mold? The answer is yes.

 

specific particles' sizes

 

Here’s an easy way to answer whether a HEPA filter will capture the particular particle you care about: Is it a particle? If yes, then yes.

 

2. Gases: activated carbon filter

The other category of air pollutants is gases. This includes chemicals that usually come from indoors—things like formaldehyde coming from furniture, chemicals coming from cleaning products, and even chemicals coming from wrinkle-free “treated” clothes.

VOCs

Gas pollutants can also come from outdoors. Outdoor gas pollutants are usually gases like NO2, SO2, and ozone, which often come from car exhaust and industry.

How do we get rid of these gases? HEPA filters won’t help because HEPAs capture particles. Instead, activated carbon will capture these bad guys.

activated carbon

Activated carbon is surprisingly versatile. I ran real-world tests to find out whether carbon works, and the data showed carbon captured volatile organic compounds coming from cigarettes (probably including a fair amount of benzene)…

 

test on activated carbon's effectiveness

formaldehyde I ordered straight from the factory…

 

formaldehyde

 

…and whatever unknown chemicals were coming out of the Smart Air office’s new flooring and wallpaper.

 

formaldehyde test

 

It’s a little bit hard to track down every single gas that carbon can capture, but scientific studies have found that carbon also captures ozone, NO2, and SO2. Thus, a simple activated carbon filter will help reduce the major gas pollutants I’m concerned about.

 

activated carbon filters Smart Air

 

So that’s it! Two filters will protect you against basically everything—at least the most common air pollutants you are likely to face.

 

Carbon Filters Have Two Important Limitations

Activated carbon filters are great, but they’re not as awesome as HEPAs. For one, HEPA filters capture 99% of particles in a single pass, but carbon filters aren’t as good. For example, this study found carbon filters captured different chemical gases anywhere between 5% to 60% in a single pass—sometimes lower.

 

Carbon also gets “full,” so the more carbon the better. Unscrupulous purifier companies put a tiny bit of carbon into a filter so they can put carbon on the spec sheet. But that carbon will get full in a hurry and then lose effectiveness.

Bottom Line: Carbon

If you’re worried about gas pollutants, look for a carbon filter with lots of carbon and change the filter frequently.

If It’s Really So Simple, Why Don’t More Air-breathers Know This?

Just two, inexpensive filters. That’s pretty awesome, right? Why don’t more people know about this?

 

One big problem is that air purifier companies don’t make money from simplicity. They make money from claiming they have proprietary technology (that they’re often unwilling to have tested by third parties), fancy imported filters (that they also don’t want tested), or some other advantage that conveniently involves you paying a few hundred more dollars.

 

One of the most common tricks out there is to package the facts above as if it’s something special about their purifier. Here’s Dyson doing just that:

 

Dyson states that their air purifiers are special

 

But What About…

But wait, you really need just two filters? Surely it’s more complicated than that. What about…

 

but wait...

 

Pre-filters?

If there’s one other filter to add to your purifier, a pre-filter is it.

 

pre-filters

Pre-filters don’t improve performance. What they do is capture large particles, which your HEPA filter would capture anyway. The benefit is that they spare your HEPA filter, allowing it to last longer.

 

Smells?

Many smells are volatile organic compounds, which means carbon filters help capture smells.

 

Washable HEPA filters?

A big problem with HEPA filters is that they eventually get full and have to be thrown away. Some companies claim to have washable HEPA filters to solve that problem. Some purifier “experts” tell you to wash your HEPA.

 

washing HEPA filters

 

The data nerds at Smart Air tested both vacuuming and washing HEPA filters, and the results showed that washing HEPA filters actually worsened performance.

 

particles captured before and after washing filters

I have yet to see an empirically proven washable HEPA filter.

 

Smoke?

First, what the heck is smoke exactly? Smoke contains particles and gases.

 

 

For particles, we know the HEPA covers us. For harmful gases like VOCs released from burning, the activated carbon filter has us covered. (But see carbon monoxide below.)

 

CO2?

Carbon dioxide will build up if people are in an enclosed, unventilated room. At moderate levels, CO2 makes people tired. At very high levels you’re unlikely to find in your home, CO2 can make people sick or even die.

 

Activated carbon filters on the market don’t meaningfully reduce CO2. Short of buying a submarine grade CO2 scrubber, the best way to reduce CO2 is to bring in outdoor air.

 

CO2 scrubber

 

Diesel exhaust?

Diesel exhaust contains gas pollutants like NO2 and particles.

 

diesel exhaust

 

HEPA filters capture the particles, and carbon filters will capture the NO2. But what about…

 

Carbon monoxide?

Experimental studies have found that activated carbon captures carbon monoxide, but I don’t know how meaningful the effect is. Carbon monoxide can be really dangerous. If I were in a room with a stove that might be putting out carbon monoxide, I would NOT rely on a carbon filter. I would move somewhere else!

 

 

Ultrafine particles?

Ultrafine particles are where the real action is, right? It’s all about the nanoparticles. I once got an email from a guy who sleeps in a plastic bubble because he’s afraid of nanoparticles in the air.

The crazy thing about HEPA filters (and Brownian motion) is that they’re actually better at capturing ultrafine particulate (< .1 microns) than particles around .1 microns (I cover some empirical demonstrations of that here and here).

 

HEPA filters ultrafine particles

 

But I’m splitting hairs. The truth is they’re incredibly good at capturing particles across the range. We’re talking about a difference between 99.X% and 99.Y%.

Bottom Line: Ultrafine particulate

You don’t need to sleep in a bubble. HEPA filters will capture ultrafine particles too.

Ionizers?

Ionizers are awesome! No filter needed, very low noise. (How ionizers work.)

 

ionizer

 

The only problem is that tests find that ionizers are terrible purifiers (1, 2). Oh, and they create ozone, which is harmful. Skip the ionizer.

 

Ozone generators?

From what I’ve read, ozone generators are pretty good purifiers. The only problem is ozone harms and even kills people. Skip the ozone generator.

 

UV light?

Some purifier companies put ultraviolet lights in purifiers because UV kills bacteria. It does, but not in the short amount of time air whips through an air purifier (according to the EPA). Skip the UV light.

 

 

Plasma-iodide-plutonium-nano-ultra technology?

If look long enough, you’ll find some claim of some technology I haven’t talked about here.

 

 

It’ll sound better. It’ll cost more. And people will want to know if it works better.

 

Is Molecule really better than other purifiers' filters

 

Before forking over your hard-earned money, remember that simple technologies (like, you know, fibers and carbon) already clean your air and are pretty cheap. If the new technology is so great, I’d wait until I see 3rd-party tests empirically demonstrating that the new technology (1) is better, (2) lasts over time, and (3) doesn’t produce some new harm we don’t know about. That sounds like a pretty high bar, but air purifiers are pretty darn good to begin with.

Breathe safe!


Covid19 coronavirus best masks materials fundraiser

Get the latest clean air tips!

Get updates on masks, air purifiers and air quality delivered straight to your inbox.

32
Leave a Reply

  Subscribe  
Notify of
Susan Frost

I was just reading an article on the hazards of a gas cooktop from an air quality standpoint. Other than converting to electric, is the best way to filter out the pollutants a carbon filter? That is what I gathered from reading this very helpful article but I want to make sure I’m not missing anything! Thanks.

Liz - Smart Air

hi Susan, Liz here. The major harmful gas your cooktop may emit would be CO, it is a gaseous pollutant. So yes the carbon filter would work. However, I wouldn’t not recommend to use an air purifier in your kitchen since the oil can easily block your filters thus shorten your filter’s lifespan; and water viper can also be adsorbed by carbon filter, so you may need to change it very frequently. If you are under risk of a cooktop CO leakage, and it always emit the gas smell in your kitchen, probably the best way is to switch to… Read more »

FClas

Thomas, you and the site are awesome – blown my mind. Clear and scientific! Thank you.

June Davis

Thomas, thank you for sharing all this info. I am extremely sensitive to many things like cleaning products, molds, and odors. Sometimes I’m aware of a pollutant and often it will trigger an immediate headache, but at other times, I will have a headache or congestion that feels like it’s a reaction to something but I don’t know what. I intend to purchase your air purifier and filters and was thinking that an air quality monitor might also be a good investment. There’s quite a diversity in prices for air quality monitors, so I’m at a loss as to what… Read more »

Liz - Smart Air

Hi June, we’ve written an article on comparing the expensive and cheap particle counters, here is the link: https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/are-cheap-particle-counters-accurate/ You can also get the answer to your question by searching keywords in our knowledge base: https://smartairfilters.com/learn/

G M

First of all, this website is so great! I have learned a lot from it! Thanks!
By the way, is there a reason why the HEPA filter is bent in zig-zag shape? Would it work the same if we lay it out flat?
And if we can lay the HEPA filter out flat, then can we use it as a mask? It would be great! Then the “HEPA mask” can last for much longer, right?!

Great question! We’ve just put the answer into our Knowledge Base, under the question “Why are HEPA filters pleated or folded into zig-zag shapes?

Tyler

I LOVE YOUR WEBSITE! Thank you for all of this useful information. My family members struggle from allergies. Fortunately, I have come up with some ways due to your website.

Liz - Smart Air

Hi Tyler, glad that helps!